| Name | Week 2 | Wk 1 |
| Bret Baldus | Baltimore | PHI |
| Janice Baldus | Detroit | KC |
| Ron Baldus | Baltimore | SEA |
| Chuck Brinkley | Carolina | GB |
| Julie Brinkley | Carolina | KC |
| Jen McMillan | Carolina | HOU |
| Scott McMillan | Carolina | SEA |
| Barb Orr | Arizona | KC |
| Sean Orr | Carolina | SEA |
| Zach Orr | Philadelphia | MIN |
| Wally Straub | Carolina | KC |
| Matt Orr | eliminated |
Friday, September 16, 2016
Week 2 Picks
